Itchy Ice Cream is a recipe seen in the Cookbook as Kelly was flipping through it. It has never been cooked before on the show, it was only seen in the book. Its first book appearances was in Just Add Mom, and the first time it was used was by RJ White, Nöelle Jasper, and Caroline in Just Add Betrayal during a flashback. The recipe was also invented by them.
- Pinch of Werpoes salt
- 1 cup milk
- 1/2 cup cream
- Plenty of ice
- to make it magical you add a secret herb of your choice